
The hidden dangers of artificial sweeteners
20 November 2026 · 5 min read
B
Brett NethellOrganised team

In our search for better health, many began to notice that sugar was in many foods deemed unhealthy, so sugar must be harmful, right? Then artificial sweeteners came along, promising all the sweetness of sugar without the sugar, but what are they hiding that we didn’t see at first?
So are artificial sweeteners actually solving an issue, or are they causing more harm than sugar ever could? Society has come to accept sugar as bad. In the UK, we even have a sugar tax which applies to certain products that exceed sugar thresholds. So how do artificial sweeteners compare, and where should you be getting your sweetness from? Read on to find out.
Sweetness without nutrition
Artificial sweeteners provide sweetness without sugar, but that also means removing nutrition. Compare this to whole-food forms of sugar, such as fruit, juice, and honey; these foods come with nutritional benefits that help support our overall health.
Honey has antimicrobial properties, polyphenols, enzymes and minerals. Fruit has potassium, vitamin C and fibre, and maple syrup has manganese. All of these are lost when we replace sugar with chemically made powders.
As I’ve covered before, when choosing a synthetic source over a natural one, we lose much more than we think we gain. Artificial sweeteners are nutritionally devoid, helping to fill a gap in taste and nothing more, but this cost can come at the expense of our health, as we’ll soon find out.

Tricking your senses
Artificial sweeteners trick your senses; your brain and body expect sweetness to come with calories and energy, but with artificial sweeteners it is followed by nothing, often zero calories.
This creates a false metabolic signal within the body. This leads to increased hunger and cravings later on. Compared with real sugar, artificial sweeteners fail to satisfy the brain and body. When we are hungry and craving sweetness, this is a signal from our body and metabolism in particular that we need fuel, and we should not ignore this signal or dismiss its root cause. When we reach for a zero-calorie sweetener instead of real whole-food sugar, our body is left waiting, which in turn causes more issues later in the day.
It's not just our brain and metabolism that are being tricked and led astray, but our insulin levels too. Since the body anticipates calories in the form of sugar when we eat something sweet, it primes insulin release. Over time, this repeated insulin priming without follow-up sugar can lead to reduced insulin sensitivity.

The ever-increasing health consequences
Recently, there have been ever-growing concerns about artificial sweeteners, ranging from cognitive function to cancer. Aspartame was the first to be classified as possibly carcinogenic in 2023, and a Brazilian study reported faster cognitive decline among those with a high intake of low- or zero-calorie sweeteners. Artificial sweeteners have also been linked to adverse changes in gut health, altering the gut microbiome.
With these ever-increasing health concerns surrounding artificial sweeteners, it begs the question: why are more and more food and supplement brands leaning into their use, just to lower their calorie count and avoid the word “sugar”?

Why have we forgotten the benefits of real sugar?
Natural sugar isn’t something to fear. Even the least-processed forms, such as raw cane sugar, are far better than any artificial alternative. Sugar represents energy, life and abundance. When nature is thriving in summer, our trees are full of sugary fruit. A diet with plenty of natural sugar signals abundance to the body.
Sugar supports the thyroid and metabolic fire, helping convert thyroid hormone T4 into active T3, replenishing liver glycogen, supporting thermogenesis and energy production, providing fuel for the brain and other glucose-dependent tissues, and reducing the need to rely heavily on stress hormones to maintain blood glucose. None of this means you need to be eating sugar by the bag, but rather not fearing natural sugar and the role it plays in health.
Across traditional food cultures, sweet and energy-dense foods were often prized for supporting: pregnancy, breastfeeding, childhood development and recovery from illness. Another ancestral truth that we have forgotten in the modern age.

The problem with “natural” alternatives
However, we couldn’t talk about sugar alternatives without mentioning the new workaround of natural sweeteners, and I don’t mean whole-food sweeteners such as honey, maple syrup and dates. I mean stevia, monk fruit and so-called “natural” flavourings. These are another way of avoiding sugar that can also come with unwanted ingredients.
For example, stevia has been linked to reduced pregnancy rates in rats, and traditional cultures would use stevia as an oral contraceptive. Stevia ranges from being ultra-processed to far less so. However, with these findings in rats and ancestral use as a contraceptive, it may be worth reconsidering its use as a sweetener.
When it comes to monk fruit, the whole fruit is very different from its extract. The extract, which is what you may see on an ingredients list, acts in the same way as zero-calorie sweeteners, providing sweetness without the satisfying sugars to back it up, once again tricking the body. It may not be as bad as artificial sweeteners, but it is still worth reconsidering, as it is often combined with erythritol, a known artificial sweetener that brings potential side effects such as stomach upset and potential cardiovascular and blood-clotting risks.
With “natural” flavouring, this goes a step further: only 10-20% needs to come from a truly natural source, while the other 80-90% may be solvents, emulsifiers, and preservatives. Since these are classed as trade secrets, they are not required to disclose what is added; it may be sweet to taste, but at what cost?
If you want something sweetened, stick to real whole foods such as honey or maple syrup and, at the very least, raw/unrefined cane sugar.

Summary
All along, we thought sugar was the problem, that sugary foods were linked to poor health, when in reality it was all the other ingredients that came with them, such as seed oils, preservatives, flavourings, and colourings. We chased sweetness to its synthetic, zero-calorie form and forgot that sweetness was also supposed to nourish us.
Our ancestors recognised the power of sugar in its whole-food form; they knew the abundance that sugar signals. This isn’t about buying cheap sugar and adding it to everything; it is about nourishing your body with sugary whole foods and no longer fearing them.






