God's Country Creamery

I've been waiting to come here for a long time and finally made it!! So much homemade yummy sounding ice-cream! I say yummy sounding because I didn't buy any but that's because home it too far away to buy and travel but I did by some pastas, cookies, and beefsticks. The pasta salad was so good! The chocolate chip cookies were perfect! Fiancé got the peanut butter cookies and he said they were so soft and yummy! I wanted so much more but we were driving around checking out fall foliage so.. next time, milk, cottage cheese, ice-cream and meats! Can't wait to go back! Worth the trip to grab some good treats! Update.. 02/16/2026.. second trip out and this place DOES NOT DISAPPOINT! Today I tried a Heaven made Brownie!! So good. I also got the Monster Cookies, haven't tried them yet. I did get buffalo cheese curds.. yum! 😋 also got some soup that I haven't tried yet but one thing I'm over the moon about. I am a huge Cottage Cheese lover. Seriously, I eat it all the time anda so picky on what brand I get. I tried their Cottage Cheese and oh my goodness! Best I have ever had. Best taste and texture! Life fan now. I can't wait to go back!

I stopped by here on a recommendation from my mother. And I was honestly very surprised it's this cute little store inside of this metal Barn looking building. Take a look at my photos because they sell all kinds of home-cooked goods. They also sell yogurt, ready to make meals, milk, eggs, this little creamery sells a lot of stuff. There's also meat I forgot to mention that. Anyway if you have time and you're in this area it's definitely worth stopping by. They only accept cash from what I could tell.

This hidden gem is tucked away in the heart of rural Pennsylvania, and it’s absolutely worth the drive. Located on a working dairy farm, the creamery operates out of a small red building that looks like it’s attached to the barn where the cows are kept—giving the experience a truly authentic, farm-fresh feel. When we walked inside, there were no staff around—it’s completely run on the honor system, which is both charming and refreshing. A freezer was stocked full of homemade, small-batch ice cream in fun and original flavors like Turtle Pond, Cow Mash, and Butter Hoof. We picked up the Black Raspberry Pie and Key Lime ice creams, and both were absolutely fantastic—some of the best ice cream we’ve ever had. Rich, creamy, and packed with flavor. In addition to ice cream, they also offered cheeses, fresh milk, eggs, desserts, beef jerky, and more—all farm-fresh and locally made. Sizes for the ice cream ranged from pints to half gallons, making it easy to grab a quick treat or stock up. The creamery is located off the beaten path in Ulysses, surrounded by what appears to be a large Amish community, adding to the rustic and peaceful charm of the area. I’m not sure if the Amish are directly involved with the business, but it definitely feels like it’s made with that same sense of quality and care. If you’re anywhere near Ulysses, this is a must-stop. Grab yourself a pint—or a few—of some of the freshest, most delicious ice cream you’ll find anywhere.

This place is awesome. Highly recommended by our good friends, the Howe's. My wife really love the raspberry cheesecake ice cream. I got a snack meat stick with Gouda cheese which was the right size and very good. We also got some jam and soap. Farm fresh, super good and we would definitely stop by again if we ever come back in the area. We're from North Dakota.