McFadyen Manor Homestead
Milton, Santa Rosa CountyRegenerative raw dairy, farm shop and eggs · Milton, Santa Rosa County
4.8 · 45 Google reviewsWhat they sell
- Raw milk
- Raw chocolate milk
- Pastured eggs
- Seasonal produce
Milton, Santa Rosa CountyRegenerative raw dairy, farm shop and eggs · Milton, Santa Rosa County
4.8 · 45 Google reviewsNo fixed hours. Weekly milk drops across the area
order through the online shop.
4.8
From 45 Google reviews
Wonderfully FRESH products and the new store is great. A real country market experience. I recommend it!
Super excited to have found you guys! We’ve been wishing we knew of a local game to buy from. You’re an answer to prayer!
Freshest food around. Beautiful farm and sweet family!!
McFayden Manor Homestead offers amazing quality raw cow milk. My whole family drank it daily for about a year, buying from the Milton Farmer's market weekly! We no longer live in Milton and I definitely miss the quality and price of their raw milk. Absolutely the best!
We have been customers of the McFadyen’s for at least two years now and have nothing but good to say about their farm. Their milk is always fresh and delicious! I have been out to their farm on numerous occasions and have seen how their animals are kept. I have complete confidence in their products and feel good about buying from them, be it milk, eggs, or meat. I am so happy they opened a new store in Milton where they offer even more products for our convenience.
We just recently visited the new store. The owner is so knowledgeable and helpful. I finally got the famous chocolate milk and loved it! Milk usually hurts my stomach, but not this stuff! We will definitely be shopping there more frequently. It’s nice to finally have a place to shop that shares the same values on quality food!
We are so lucky to have found this farm! The quality of everything they offer is truly outstanding. The raw milk is incredibly fresh, rich, and flavorful (says our animals)—nothing like what you’ll find in a store, unless it's their store. Their eggs are just as amazing, with deep golden yolks that show how well the chickens are cared for. What really sets this place apart, though, is the people behind it. They are genuinely kind, knowledgeable, and passionate about what they do. You can tell they take excellent care of their animals, giving them a healthy, happy environment—and it shows in the quality of their products. It’s rare to find a farm that combines such high standards with such warm, personal service. We trust them completely and are grateful to support a local business that truly does things the right way. Highly recommend to anyone looking for fresh, wholesome, responsibly sourced food!
My husband and I have been getting our milk from McFayden Manor Homestead every single week for over a year now, and we absolutely love it. It has truly become a staple in our household. My husband (rightfully) scowls at store bought milk nowadays because it just can’t compare to the fresh product we’ve become accustomed to. We usually pick up straight from the farm, and it’s always such a peaceful experience—getting to see the cows and other animals right by the fence always makes me smile. You can tell immediately that the animals are well cared for, happy, and raised with intention. That alone speaks volumes about the kind of operation they run. The owners are just as incredible as the farm itself. They are some of the most personable, hardworking, and genuinely kind people you’ll meet. It’s clear they truly care about their animals, their products, and the community they serve. There have been multiple times when we were running late from work, and they went out of their way to meet us at the gate with our order—something you just don’t find everywhere, especially from such a busy operation. The quality of their products is unmatched. The milk is always incredibly fresh, and we love that it’s stored in glass instead of plastic. We have also tried many of their other offerings such as homemade vanilla, eggs and meat products.. everything has been consistently excellent. McFayden Manor Homestead is truly a gem in our community. We are so grateful to have access to such high-quality, thoughtfully produced food from people who clearly pour their heart into what they do. Highly, highly recommend!
I have be buying Milk from this farm for 2yrs+ and have NEVER received a bad batch or anything less than perfect product! I buy 1-2 gallons WEEKLY! And although this product is intended for animal consumption- I started drinking it myself and have literally went from being lactose sensitive with processed milk to having absolutely no stomach issues when drinking this milk! I stand by the Mcfadyen family and ALL their products 💯 % they are genuine hardworking folks that are a true blessing to our community & especially my family! Highly recommend!
McFadyen Manor Homestead is a regenerative Jersey dairy in Milton, Florida, selling raw grass fed milk, chocolate milk, pastured eggs and seasonal produce from over 20 cows.
McFadyen Manor Homestead is a small regenerative farmstead and dairy in Milton, Northwest Florida, started in 2019 by Caitlin and Nate McFadyen. Nate trained in dairy herd management, and what began as one three quartered Jersey cow named Snooki in 2021 has grown to a herd of more than 20 Jerseys, with calves born on the farm year round. The long growing season and plentiful rain let them produce grass fed milk on pasture 365 days a year.
The farm sells unpasteurised, non homogenised whole milk and chocolate milk made with organic cocoa and locally sourced honey, farm fresh eggs from free ranging pastured chickens, and seasonal produce grown without chemical fertilisers, herbicides or pesticides. The cows are moved around the land and milked twice a day, and the farm uses no vaccines and no antibiotics. Under Florida law the raw milk is labelled not for human consumption and sold as animal feed.
Caitlin McFadyen
Co-owner
Grew up in suburban Florida, always drawn to animals; left a finance career to raise a family in the country.
Nate McFadyen
Co-owner
Holds a degree in dairy herd management from Michigan; left construction to run the dairy.
We will email you when a new farm joins the map near you.
Unsubscribe anytime.