Valley Shepherd Creamery
Valley Shepherd Creamery is a working sheep dairy in Long Valley, New Jersey making over fifty artisan dairy products, including many raw milk cheeses, sheep milk yogurt and cultured butter.
Valley Shepherd Creamery is a working sheep dairy on 120 rolling acres at Long Valley in Morris County, New Jersey, within an hour of New York City.
Old world European dairy farming meets modern cheesemaking kit here, and the creamery milks its own animals to make over fifty artisan dairy products, aging its cheeses in a cave on the farm.
Visitors can tour the farm and watch a real working dairy in action, then shop the cheeses, yogurts and butters at the farm store, open Thursday to Saturday from 10am to 5pm and Sunday from 11am to 5pm. There is an online shop for orders further afield.
What they sell
- Raw milk cheese
- Cave aged cheese
- Sheep milk yogurt
- Goat cheese
- Cultured butter
Plan your visit
- You can visit in person
- Delivers locally
From the community
4.8
From 134 Google reviews
Amazing, quality products and service!!
Incredible quality products with nothing but the best ingredients.
Best ever, especially for little guy.
Amazing hidden gem!!









