Alan
Co founder and cheesemaker
A food scientist by training specialising in dairy cultures, who fell in love with raw milk cheese during a summer working in Holland.
5 Spoke Creamery
5 Spoke Creamery is a solar powered dairy farm and creamery in Goshen, New York making kosher raw milk cheeses from pastured grass fed cows, sold online and in stores.
5 Spoke Creamery makes handmade raw milk cheeses on a 100 year old dairy farm in Goshen, New York, 57 miles north of New York City.
Barbara and Alan, a food scientist trained in dairy cultures, bought the dilapidated farm and brought it back to life, restoring the barn and milk house and building a below ground European style aging room with a cheese making room above. The operation is 100 percent solar powered, the first cheese making facility in New York State to be exclusively so.
The cheeses start with raw milk from pastured, free roaming, grass fed cows, and the range runs from Welsh and Redmond cheddars to Harvest Moon, Forager, Tumbleweed, Crawford and Browning Gold, all small batch and kosher. The creamery is a member of the American Cheese Society, the New York State Cheese Council and the Weston A. Price Foundation, and sells directly through its online shop, at farmers markets and through stores found via its where to buy tool.
What they sell
- Raw milk cheeses
- Welsh cheddar
- Redmond cheddar
- Harvest Moon
- Forager
- Tumbleweed
- Crawford
- Browning Gold
Plan your visit
- You can visit in person
- Delivers locally
1089 Pulaski Hwy, Goshen, NY 10924
Opening times
No fixed hours. Contact the farm to arrange a visit.
Ask the farm
We do not hold prices, availability, parking, access details or event dates for 5 Spoke Creamery. The farm answers those directly on its own site or by phone.
Contact
- Websitewww.5spokecreamery.com
Meet the farm team
From the community
4.1
From 18 Google reviews
17 June 2026
Creamy cheese 😋 ultra delicious!!
13 September 2025
The five Book creamery is a great place with an awesome owner, very knowledgeable and experienced cheese maker.
8 March 2025
The website says if you are local you can buy cheese and go to the farm to pick it up to not pay shipping. I sent a message to them saying what I wanted to buy and got a message back saying my message was being sent to the husband who would coordinate a time to come pick up the cheese. A week went by with no response so I sent another message and then just got ghosted. It has been weeks with no response. I guess they don't actually want to sell to local people who want to pickup the cheese and I just wasted my time. Too bad, local raw cheese sounded like an awesome thing I wanted to be a good part of me and my families diet.
