Matt Fagan
Owner
Runs the family dairy at Cambridge City with Jamie and their six children.
Fagan Family Farm
Fagan Family Farm is a family dairy farm in Cambridge City, Indiana providing raw milk from grass fed cows through a herd share program, plus locally raised freezer beef.
Fagan Family Farm is a family dairy farm at Cambridge City, Indiana, milking grass fed cows and sharing the milk through a herd share scheme.
Indiana law does not allow raw milk to be sold directly, so customers buy a share in the herd instead, which entitles them to a weekly gallon of fresh, unpasteurised, non homogenised milk.
Shares are a one off purchase with a weekly boarding fee on top, and milk is collected from the farm or from pick up points run by helpers in surrounding towns. The family also sell locally raised beef. Farm visits are strictly by appointment, so call ahead before heading out.
What they sell
- Raw milk herd shares
- Freezer beef
Plan your visit
- You can visit in person
- Delivers locally
Meet the farm team
From the community
5.0
From 7 Google reviews
12 February 2025
The absolute best place to get fresh milk through a herdshare program! We’ve been living on this milk for over six years now.
30 July 2024
Milk(from the herdshare) is the most creamy and delicious I've ever had. Owner is incredibly nice and welcoming. Farm is beautiful and well maintained.
9 June 2023
Great family!
