1 of 3
What they sell
- Raw A2 milk
- Pasteurised milk
- Cheese
- Farm fresh eggs
- Maple syrup
Visit
141 miles
Opening timesMonday to Saturday, 7am to 9pm
16927 Tavern Rd, Middlefield, OH 44062141 miles away from you
You can visit in personNo delivery
What people say
4.9
From 46 Google reviews
17 October 2026
Highly recommend if you're looking for local milk and cream. Organic and Kosher certified! Now serving ice cream and yogurt along with PET milk, Keifer and butter.
17 September 2026
This will definitely become a regular visit for me. Retail milk is nasty to me because it all tastes like plastic. Smith milk, when it was around, was the exception. After they were bought out, I found this place, and am in heaven. At first, I was taken aback by the yellow color. I'm used to white milk. But I did my homework and found out about grass-fed cows and beta-carotine. Now I'm hooked. The store itself is simple, we'll laid out, and on the honor system... with the cigarette butt-type 'cash drawers. Ingenious.
27 August 2026
They keep adding new products. Seems like a nice local business.
About the farm
Old Country Creamery is an Amish family dairy in Middlefield, Ohio selling A2 non GMO milk and cheese in raw and pasteurised form, plus farm fresh eggs and maple syrup from the farm.
Old Country Creamery is a small dairy in Middlefield, Ohio, making farm fresh dairy in small batches. The milk comes from pasture raised cows and is free from artificial additives, hormones and antibiotics, and traditional methods with minimal processing keep the natural richness and flavour of the milk.
The creamery sells fresh milk, butter, cheese and yoghurt direct, open Monday to Saturday from early morning until evening.
Nearby farms
Show all
170 miles · Raw milk, butcher
106 miles · Raw milk, eggs
Keep exploring
Hear when a farm opens near you
We will email you when a new farm joins the map near you.
Unsubscribe anytime.
