Bone Broth vs Collagen: What Reddit Says You Actually Need
Bone broth or collagen powder? Reddit argues this one endlessly, usually with strong opinions and shaky facts. Here is what the threads genuinely agree on, where they get confused, and what the evidence says about whether you need one, the other, or both.
By Niall Kiddle, Founder, Organised
Reviewed by Pedro Rodrigues, Agronomist (farming and sourcing only) ·
4 min read · Published
Makers of the Organised Daily blend, a grass-fed beef organ supplement from regenerative UK farms
The matchup turns up in r/Supplements, r/nutrition, r/xxfitness and the various skincare subs. Because both products are built on collagen, people assume they are interchangeable, then get into long threads about which is 'better'. The honest answer needs the questions separated.
What people actually ask on Reddit
The real questions are: which one does more for skin and joints, is bone broth's collagen dose high enough to matter, is collagen powder just isolated broth, and is it worth paying for both. People are trying to avoid buying two things that do the same job.
The better threads make a clean distinction: bone broth is a food with a variable, usually modest collagen dose plus minerals and gelatin, while collagen powder is a concentrated, measured dose of collagen peptides and little else.
What Reddit tends to get right
- Collagen powder delivers a bigger, more reliable dose. The crowd correctly notes that a scoop of hydrolysed collagen gives you a known, meaningful amount, whereas a mug of broth is unpredictable and usually lower.
- Bone broth is more than collagen. Good threads point out that broth also provides gelatin, minerals, electrolytes and glycine, and is genuinely nourishing as a food. It is not just weak collagen. That glycine matters more than it sounds: it balances the methionine and tryptophan concentrated in muscle meat, which is exactly the balance that eating nose to tail (bones, skin and connective tissue, not only the steak) is meant to restore.
- Peptides are easier to absorb. Redditors are right that hydrolysed collagen is pre-broken-down for absorption, while broth's gelatin is a larger molecule your gut has to work on.
- They are complementary, not rivals. The most upvoted mature take is that this is not really a versus at all: broth is a warming, mineral-rich food and collagen powder is a convenient targeted dose. Many people happily use both.
The grown-up Reddit take: collagen powder is a reliable measured dose, bone broth is a nourishing food with minerals and a variable collagen amount. It is complementary, not a competition.
Where the threads go wrong
"Bone broth has tons of collagen." The amount in a typical homemade or shop-bought broth varies enormously and is often well below the doses used in collagen studies. People overestimate it because it feels wholesome.
"Collagen powder is a scam, just drink broth." The reverse error. If a measured collagen dose is your goal, broth is an inconsistent way to get there. Dismissing the powder ignores why the trials use it.
"Broth heals your gut lining directly." The glycine and gelatin in broth are genuinely soothing and useful, but the strong 'heals leaky gut' claims that circulate on Reddit run ahead of the evidence. Broth is nourishing food, not a cure.
Ignoring vitamin C. Both camps often forget that collagen synthesis needs vitamin C, so whichever you choose, the cofactors matter. Your body also builds collagen using minerals like copper and zinc, which broth and organ foods supply alongside the protein, and the easiest source of the vitamin C itself is ripe fruit rather than a supplement.
Get honest comparisons, free
Two short reads a week cutting through supplement marketing with what the evidence says.
By signing up you agree to receive emails from us. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
What the evidence says
For a measured effect on skin elasticity or joint comfort, the studies overwhelmingly use hydrolysed collagen peptides at defined daily doses, so the powder is the more reliable tool if that is your specific target. Bone broth earns its place as a genuinely nourishing whole food: gelatin, glycine, minerals and electrolytes in a form people actually enjoy, which supports adherence in a way a scoop of flavourless powder sometimes does not. Glycine is the amino acid doing much of that quiet work, and broth is also one of the oldest traditional foods, valued across cultures for exactly those minerals and gelatin, and at its best made from grass-fed bones. Our comparison of bone broth vs collagen supplements works through the dosing and the use cases in detail.
The sensible conclusion mirrors Reddit's better threads: if you want a predictable dose for skin or joints, collagen powder; if you want a warming, mineral-rich food, broth; and there is no contradiction in using both.
1 of 9
Daily blend
100,000+ thriving families4.9 on Trustpilot
Eight real ingredients built around grass-fed beef organs, collagen and colostrum. Nothing synthetic added.
Free with your first order, worth £38. Plus £10 off the pouch with a subscription.
Free UK shipping · Made in England · 100 day money back guarantee on your first pouch · Skip, pause or cancel anytime
Common questions
Is bone broth or collagen better according to Reddit?
For a reliable, measured collagen dose targeting skin or joints, the consensus favours collagen powder. For nourishing food with minerals and glycine, broth wins. Most experienced posters use them for different jobs.
Does bone broth have enough collagen to matter?
Sometimes, but the amount varies a lot and is often below the doses used in collagen studies. If a specific dose matters to you, powder is more dependable than broth.
Do I need both bone broth and collagen?
You do not need both, but they are complementary. Broth is a food, collagen powder is a targeted dose. Plenty of Redditors use broth as nourishment and powder for a consistent daily amount.
Which is better for skin, bone broth or collagen?
For skin specifically, hydrolysed collagen peptides are what the trials use and what most threads recommend, because the dose is measured and the peptides absorb well. Broth helps as food but is less predictable.
The bottom line
Reddit's honest verdict is that bone broth vs collagen is a false fight. Collagen powder gives you a reliable, study-backed dose for skin and joints, bone broth gives you a nourishing, mineral-rich food. Choose by the job you want done, remember the vitamin C, and feel free to use both. Neither is a scam and neither is magic.
Who wrote and reviewed this guide
Niall Kiddle
Author · Founder, Organised
Niall is the founder of Organised. He started the company in 2024 after fixing his own health the slow way: in 2022 he swapped a cupboard of synthetic supplements for real food, raw milk, organ meats, bone broth and honey, and felt the difference within months.
Areas of expertise: Ancestral nutrition, Organ meats, Whole-food supplementation, Gut health, Regenerative sourcing
Read Niall's full profile
Pedro Rodrigues
Reviewer · Agronomist (farming and sourcing only)
Pedro is the agronomist Organised works with on farming and sourcing. His job on the guides is to keep the science honest: he reviews what we publish about soil health, regenerative agriculture, grazing and the way food is actually produced.
Areas of expertise: Regenerative agriculture, Agronomy, Soil health, Grass-fed farming, Food sourcing
Reviewed this guide on
Read Pedro's full profileMore on nutrient comparisons
View all- Beef Liver vs Multivitamin: A Side-by-Side Nutrient Comparison
- Beef Organs vs Desiccated Liver: Why a Blend Is Better
- Beef Protein vs Plant Protein: A Nutritional Reality Check
- Bone Broth vs Collagen Supplements: Do You Need Both?
- Bovine Colostrum vs Goat Colostrum: Does the Source Matter?
- Celtic Sea Salt vs Table Salt: A Mineral Analysis
- Collagen vs Hyaluronic Acid: What Actually Works for Skin?
- Folate from Liver vs Folic Acid from Supplements
- Grass-Fed Collagen vs Marine Collagen vs Vegan Collagen
- Methylcobalamin vs Cyanocobalamin: Which B12 Is Better?
- Retinol from Food vs Retinol in Supplements: Bioavailability Compared
Browse the guides library
All guidesKeep reading
Comparisons
Bone Broth vs Collagen Supplements: Do You Need Both?
Both give you collagen and glycine. But the nutrient profile is completely different. Here's what each actually provides.
Comparisons
Celtic Sea Salt vs Table Salt: A Mineral Analysis
Celtic sea salt contains 84 minerals vs table salt's zero. Why the difference matters for electrolyte balance and your nervous system.
Comparisons
Beef Liver vs Spirulina: Which Is Really the Superfood?
Which is truly nutrient-dense? Compare beef liver and spirulina nutrient for nutrient, including retinol, B12, and contamination risk. You might be surprised.
Real food, made effortless
Try the blendA few ways to use it
All recipes
Energy Balls with Organised, Dates and Raw Honey
Make no-bake energy balls with Organised, dates, and raw honey. Perfect lunch box, pre-workout, or on-the-go snack. Simple recipe.
How to Make Bone Marrow Butter
Roast grass-fed marrow bones, scoop the marrow, and mix with butter and herbs. A nutrient-dense spread with fat-soluble vitamins.
Gut-Healing Marshmallows with Collagen and Raw Honey
Learn to make gut-healing marshmallows with collagen and raw honey. A shareable treat that sneaks nutrition into every bite. Easy recipe with video tips.
Join over 100,000+ membersBuild a better food system with us
The Organised community is thousands of people choosing real food and backing the farmers who grow it, all of us trying to leave the world a little better than we found it. If that is what you care about too, you belong here.